🚨 BREAKING: $1.5M "PAY-TO-PLAY" OFFER DAYS BEFORE NOV. 16 VOTE • Details →

Stop Fearrington Preserve

"IT'S NOT A COMPACT COMMUNITY!"
URGENT WEEKEND ACTION ALERT · FINAL VOTE MONDAY, NOV. 16 @ 6:00 PM

Pay to Play? Developer Puts $1.5M on the Table Out of Public View

After losing on the merits—recommended for DENIAL by County Planning Staff and rejected 8–3 by the Planning Board—the developer has quietly offered the County $1.5 million days before Monday's final vote. No review board has seen it, it isn't posted in the public case file, and by the developer's own math it covers just 7 months of the $2.47M/year this project will cost Chatham taxpayers forever.

What is Smart Chatham? We are a non-partisan coalition of neighborhood associations (Briar Chapel, Fearrington Village, Kentview North/South, Morris Road, Parker Herndon Road, Andrews Store Road, Polks Landing), parents, and environmental stewards. We support smart, policy-compliant growth—not eleventh-hour backroom deals.

$1.5M = 7 Mos. Of $2.47M/Yr County Cost
109+ Acres Canopy Clear-Cut
Toxic Land Concealed Reports
4 Schools Negatively Impacted

DEEP DIVES & EXPLAINERS

Latest News & Updates

URGENT ACTION ALERT · FINAL VOTE MONDAY, NOV 16 @ 6:00 PM

Tell the Board of Commissioners: Reject the $1.5M "Pay-to-Play" Deal & Vote NO

After losing on the merits before County Planning Staff and the Planning Board (8–3 Denial), the developer quietly put an unvetted $1.5M offer on the table days before Monday's vote. Send a 1-click email to all five County Commissioners demanding transparency and a final NO vote.

Choose Your Message Focus:

To (All 5 Commissioners): Karen Howard, Amanda Robertson, Katie Kenlan, Franklin Gomez Flores, Mike Roberson

CC: Bryan Thompson (County Manager), Jenifer Johnson (Clerk to the Board), Jason Sullivan (Planning Director)

BCC: Smart Chatham Campaign Log (comments@smartchatham.org)

Subject: Reject the $1.5M "Pay-to-Play" Offer — Vote NO on Fearrington Preserve


CORE DENIAL ARGUMENTS

The Four Strategic Policy Pillars

Four technical, environmental, and legal reasons why the Planning Board must recommend DENIAL.

Pillar 1 — Due Process & Lack of Transparency

Procedural Defects, Defective Notice & The Secret NDA

  • 100+ Pages of Late Overhauls: Submitted across open hearing sessions, introducing major structural modifications that bypass required re-reviews by the Technical Review Committee (TRC) and Appearance Commission.
  • Secret County NDA: Cloaks site-wide technical, environmental, and site suitability studies covering the entire property, violating public inspection principles under N.C.G.S. § 160D-602 and state public records law (N.C.G.S. Chapter 132).
  • N.C.G.S. § 160D-602 Notice: Evaluating a "moving target" application with un-noticed, substantially different plans renders original statutory notice legally defective under the Substantial Changes Rule established by the NC Supreme Court in Heaton v. City of Charlotte and NC Court of Appeals precedent in Thrash v. County of Buncombe.
Impacts: Neighboring Property Notice & Constitutional Rights
Pillar 2 — Ordinance Exploitation

Double Density Without Compliance

  • 77% Commercial Town Center Slash: Cuts required 100,000 sq. ft. walkable village down to ~23,000 sq. ft. (or 0 if converted to townhomes).
  • 50% Viewshed Buffer Cuts: Shrinks required roadside buffers along Parker Herndon and Morris Roads from 100 ft to 50 ft.
  • Extreme Net Pod Density (5.77 Units/Ac Net): Concentrates 630 homes into 5 disconnected pods separated by streams, lacking internal walkability.
Impacts: Parker Herndon Rd, Morris Rd & Compact Ordinance Rules
Pillar 3 — Environmental Hazards

Flooding, Forest Loss & Wastewater

  • Outdated FEMA Maps & Bridge Washouts: Relies on inaccurate flood boundaries on Pokeberry Creek—a stream that has washed out Morris Rd bridges twice in 7 years.
  • 109+ Acres Clear-Cut: Destroys mature forest canopy, accelerating peak stormwater runoff and soil erosion into local waterways.
  • Off-Site Sewer Barred & Remediation Failure: Zoning Staff confirmed off-site sewer to Fearrington Place is prohibited. Furthermore, stream restoration fails without Briar Chapel access easements.
Impacts: Kentview Dr, Morris Rd & Pokeberry Creek Watershed
Pillar 4 — Safety & Traffic

Traffic Gridlock & School Corridors

  • Failing Level of Service (LOS E & F): TIA projects failing intersections on narrow two-lane rural collector roads.
  • 4 Local Schools Impacted: Dumps traffic from 630 homes directly onto pickup/drop-off routes for Pollard Middle, Chatham Grove Elementary, Woods Charter and Willow Oak Montessori.
  • Unstudied Roundabouts & Bus Safety: Inserts unapproved roundabouts on Andrews Store Rd and lacks guaranteed internal bus turnaround loops in every pod.
Impacts: Andrews Store Rd, Parker Herndon Rd & School Corridors
3% Cover the Fee

Note: Smart Chatham is a tax-exempt social welfare organization under Section 501(c)(4) of the Internal Revenue Code. Contributions or gifts to Smart Chatham are not tax-deductible as charitable contributions for federal income tax purposes.