Pay to Play? Developer Puts $1.5 Million on the Table Days Before Fearrington Preserve Vote, Out of Public View

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
Date:
November 13, 2026
Contact: Jeremy Rose, Smart Chatham · 630-835-6049 · press@smartchatham.org · SmartChatham.org

No County review board has seen it. No financial analysis supports it. Smart Chatham calls on commissioners to reject the deal and deny the rezoning.

PITTSBORO, NC — Four days before the Chatham County Board of Commissioners votes on the Fearrington Preserve rezoning, Smart Chatham has learned that the applicant, Fearrington Property Development, LLC, has put $1.5 million on the table for the County as a proposed condition of approval. What the money is for has not been disclosed.

This rezoning has already failed every test the County put in front of it. County planning staff recommended denial. The Planning Board voted 8–3 against it and found it inconsistent with Plan Chatham. Now, with the vote days away, a seven-figure sweetener appears.

"Residents have spent fourteen months doing this the right way: reading every filing, showing up to every hearing, playing by the rules," said Jeremy Rose of Smart Chatham. "The developer lost on the merits, and now money shows up at the last minute, outside every review the County requires. That looks like pay-to-play, and Chatham County residents deserve better. Commissioners should say no."

Kept out of public view

As of 9:00 AM, November 13, 2026, the County's online file for the case contained no document describing the $1.5 million, even though public comments are routinely posted within a day. Smart Chatham filed a public records request on November 12, 2026. The County's reply: "We can begin working on the request, but we will not have it done by Monday."

Citizens are being asked to accept a secret deal they cannot read.

It skipped every review

Every County review of this project was finished before the money appeared. None of these bodies has evaluated it:

  • Environmental Review Advisory Committee (determination April 9)

  • Technical Review Committee (last review July 15)

  • County planning staff (written recommendation of denial; their draft conditions include no such payment)

  • Planning Board (8–3 vote to recommend denial, October 6)

  • The public (hearings April 20, May 18 and July 27)

A condition this large, added this late, deserves the same scrutiny as everything else. It has had none.

A financial deal with no financial analysis

County rules require a fiscal impact analysis for this project, checked by a County-hired peer reviewer. That analysis dates to August 2025; the peer review to October 2025. Nothing in the record explains where $1.5 million came from, what it pays for, or whether it covers anything at all. 

The applicant's own numbers show how little it is:

  • About $2,400 per home across the up to 630 homes the rezoning would allow.

  • Less than one year of County property tax on those homes (roughly $3,200 per home per year, by the applicant's estimate).

  • About seven months of the $2.47 million a year the applicant projects the project will cost the County in services, including $1.67 million a year for schools.

A one-time payment that covers seven months of costs, for a project that lasts forever.

What the law says

Under N.C.G.S. § 160D-703(b), a zoning condition must address the project's own impacts or its conformance with County plans, and the applicant must agree to it in writing. A payment with no stated purpose fails the most basic question: what is this money for?

Questions commissioners must answer before Monday

  1. Who negotiated this $1.5 million, with whom, and when?

  2. Is it in writing, signed by the applicant? Why isn't it posted?

  3. What does it pay for, and which impact of the project does it address?

  4. What analysis supports the number, and has the County's peer reviewer seen it?

  5. Why should a condition that skipped every review be voted on at all?

Our ask

Reject the $1.5 million and deny the rezoning, as County staff and the Planning Board recommended. Zoning in Chatham County should be decided on the merits, in public, not settled by a last-minute payment no one has been allowed to examine.

Smart Chatham is reviewing all options to hold this process accountable.

About Smart Chatham. Smart Chatham is a non-partisan coalition of neighborhood groups, parents and community members across Chatham County.


Previous
Previous

Developer throws down extra $1.5M ahead of Chatham’s Fearrington Preserve review

Next
Next

Does this look like a "small path" to you? Unapproved roadway cut off Alex Cockman Rd before Commissioners even vote